Skip to content

Extend the tests in regexp/inspect_spec with over escaping combined with character classes #987

@herwinw

Description

@herwinw

The specs have one test for escaped backslashes in Regexp#inspect:

it "does not over escape" do
  Regexp.new('\\\/').inspect.should == "/\\\\\\//"
end

The obvious implementation to make this spec pass is to simply escape every slash with another slash. This works in this case, but that causes an error in language/case_spec for something that is not related to the case statement:

it "tests with a regexp interpolated within another regexp" do
  digits_regexp = /\d+/
  case "foo43"
  when /oo(#{digits_regexp})/

This results in a regexp /oo(?-mix:\\d+)/, which now expects a slash followed by one or more d characters. This does not match the input, but does not indicate the escaping as the issue.

I tested my implementation with the these specs added, but this was more or less brute forcing every possibility. Also, because Regexp.new takes a String which has an additional layer of escaping, I peferred the // notation.

Regexp.new('\d+').inspect.should == "/\\d+/"
/\d+/.inspect.should == "/\\d+/"

Regexp.new('\\d+').inspect.should == "/\\d+/"
/\\d+/.inspect.should == "/\\\\d+/"

Regexp.new('\\\d+').inspect.should == "/\\\\d+/"
/\\\d+/.inspect.should == "/\\\\\\d+/"

Regexp.new('\\\\d+').inspect.should == "/\\\\d+/"
/\\\\d+/.inspect.should == "/\\\\\\\\d+/"

I think it would be better to at least include the following cases:

/\d+/ # Output should have 1 not escaped slash, since this should not be escaped
/\\d+/ # Output should have 1 escaped slash (so 2 slashes), this should be escaped
/\\\d+/ # Output should have 1 escaped and 1 not escaped slash (so 3 slashes)

Furthermore, I think it would be better to add an explicit test for the regexp embedded in regexp scenario like there is in the case spec now, just to make the test a bit more explicit and decouple it from the case statement.

I'm not that familiar with this project and how things are structured, can I just add a few tests to the inspect spec of regexp, and make a new spec file for the embedding tests?

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions